Skip to main content
  • Sportsdykkeren.dk 🇩🇰
  • XRay-Mag.SE 🇸🇪
  • Dykmässan (diveshow)

Secondary menu - Advertising and subscriptions

  • Got stories? - Guidelines
  • Advertising
  • Subscribe to X-Ray Mag
Home
  • Magazine
  • News
      1. Latest news
      2. Press releases
      3. Breaking News
  • Travel
      1. Destinations
        1. Australia & New Zealand
        2. Continental Asia
          • Japan
          • China
          • South Korea
        3. Southeast Asia
          • Indonesia
            • Bali
            • Komodo
            • Lembeh
            • Maluku
            • Raja Ampat
            • Sulawesi
          • Malaysia
          • Papua New Guinea
          • Philippines
          • Thailand
          • Timor-Leste
        4. South Pacific & Oceania
          • Fiji
          • French Polynesia
          • Micronesia
            • Chuuk (Truk)
            • Marshall Islands
            • Yap
          • Palau
          • Samoa
          • Solomon Islands
          • Tonga
          • Vanuatu
        5. Indian Ocean
          • Madagascar
          • Maldives
          • Seychelles
        6. Red Sea
        7. Africa
          • Egypt
          • Malawi
          • Mozambique
          • Namibia
          • South Africa
          • Sudan
          • Tanzania
        8. Mediterranean & Adriatic
          • Croatia
          • Cyprus
          • France
          • Greece
          • Italy
          • Malta & Gozo
          • Portugal
          • Spain
          • Turkey
        9. Europe
          • Northern Europe
            • Denmark
            • England
            • Finland
            • Iceland
            • Ireland
            • Norway
            • Scotland
            • Sweden
          • Eastern Europe
            • Albania
            • Bosnia-Hercegovina
            • Croatia
            • Czech Republic
            • Hungary
            • Poland
            • Russia
              • Northwest Russia
              • Russian Far East
              • Siberia
          • Western Europe
            • Austria
            • France
            • Germany
            • Switzerland
          • Southern Europe
            • Cyprus
            • Greece
            • Italy
            • Malta & Gozo
            • Portugal
            • Spain
        10. Atlantic
          • Azores
          • Canary Islands
          • Falkland Islands
          • St Helena
        11. North America
          • Canada
          • Great Lakes
          • United States
            • East Coast
            • West coast
            • Alaska
            • Hawaii
            • US Virgin Islands
            • Guam
          • Mexico
        12. Caribbean & Central America
          • Bahamas
          • Belize
          • Cayman Islands
          • Bonaire
          • Cuba
          • Dominican Republic
          • Mexico
          • Columbia
          • Grenada
          • Costa Rica
          • Saba
          • Honduras
          • Turks & Caicos
          • US Virgin Islands
          • Nicaragua
        13. South America
          • Argentina
          • Brazil
          • Ecuador
        14. Polar Regions
          • Artic
          • Antarctica
      2. Promotions
      3. My Favorite Dive
  • Ecology
      1. Ocean Mysteries series by Ila France Porcher
      2. Sharks, Rays and Nudibranch stories by Andy Murch
      3. Sentience
      4. Conservation
      5. Coral Reefs
      6. Dolphins
      7. Fish
      8. Jellyfish
      9. Mantas & Stingrays
      10. Nudibranchs
      11. Octopus & Squid
      12. Sea Turtles
      13. Seals & Sea Lions
      14. Sharks
      15. Whales
  • Wrecks
      1. Vic Verlinden
      2. Ancient Wrecks
      3. Artificial Reefs
      4. Marine Archaeology
      5. Older Warships
      6. Steamships & Cargo
      7. Tall & Wooden Ships
      8. WWI Wrecks
      9. WWII Wrecks
  • Training & Tech
      1. Rebreathers
      2. Sidemount
      3. Deep Wrecks
      4. Cave Diving & Mines
      5. Ice Diving
      6. Diver Health & Safety
        1. Divers Alert Network - DAN
        2. Safety Culture
      7. Adaptive Diving
  • More
      1. Equipment
        1. BCDs, Wings & Sidemounts
        2. Dive Computers
        3. Dive Watches
        4. Drysuits & Undergarments
        5. Hoods, Gloves & Boots
        6. Lamps & Torches
        7. Masks, Fins & Snorkels
        8. Regulators
        9. Wetsuits & Rashguards
      2. Photo & Video
        1. Equipment
          • Cameras & Optics
          • Editing & Post-processing
          • Housings
          • Lighting
          • Useful Tools
        2. Tutorials
          • Techniques & Tips
            • Mike Bartick
            • Rico Besserdich
          • Composition
          • Editing & Post-processing
        3. News & Announcements
        4. Contributors' Picks
      3. Books & Media
        1. Works by our contributors
      4. Profiles & Interviews
        1. In Memoriam
      5. Lifestyle
        1. Portfolios & Ocean Arts
        2. Apres Dive & Apparel
        3. Editorials
      6. Contributors
        1. Pundits
          • Mike Ange
          • Gareth Lock
          • Michael Menduno
          • Mark Powell
          • Simon Pridmore
        2. Regular writers
          • Scott Bennett
          • Andrey Bizyukin
          • Larry Cohen & Olga Torrey
          • Pierre Constant
          • Brent Durand
          • Jennifer Idol
          • Scott Johnson
          • Steve Jones
          • Kate Jonker
          • Kelly LaClaire & Kate Holt
          • Matthew Meier
          • Brandi Mueller
          • Svetlana Murashkina
          • Barb Roy
          • Don Silcock
          • Claudia Weber-Gebert
          • Lawson Wood
        3. Columnists
          • Scott Bennett
          • Rico Besserdich
          • Rosemary 'Roz' E. Lunn
          • Ila France Porcher
  • ⚲ Search

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Justice for All Sentient Beings?

Justice for All Sentient Beings?

August 31, 2023 • Op'eds and commentaries
Profile picture for user Chief minion
By Chief minion on
  • facebook-f
  • twitter
  • envelope
  • print

What counts as sentient? We can't know. I therefore do not take anything for granted but acknowledge that even the smallest and seemingly insignificant creature just might be capable of some degree of sentience.

Photographer, source or credit: psymes

I am therefore I think. Because I think, justice should also be extended to me?

Photographer/credit
psymes
Sentience
Editorial

Most of us will agree that we should not be cruel to animals but treat them nicely. We have animal welfare laws in place, for example, and pet owners will testify that their animals—often considered members of the family—have personalities and feelings. It is also widely accepted that a number of wild animals possess considerable intelligence and social skills, such as primates, marine animals, and some birds, to name a few.

Some animals even have certain rights or protections. Neglecting or mistreating pets or livestock is, in most places, a crime and animal welfare laws dictate that livestock should be provided with tolerable living conditions and enough stimuli, and they should not suffer any unnecessary pain.

But which animals do such rights and duty of care extend to? Just the familiar species, such as those we keep as pets, raise as livestock, or think are cute?

How about the sentient beings we encounter in the ocean? 

Our appreciation of sharks has come a long way since the days when they were considered fearsome monsters and single-minded eating machines to our current understanding of them today as quite intelligent and sentient beings, with social interactions and structure. But does that mean they should also have legal rights?   

The prominent philosopher and ethicist Martha Nussbaum thinks so.

Her “Capabilities Approach” is a philosophical framework that aims to provide a more comprehensive and human-centred perspective for evaluating well-being and social justice.

In her recent book, Justice for Animals (which I aim to review in the future), she argues for an expansion of her influential approach, to encompass all sentient beings. She makes a good case albeit one fraught with challenges, including some cultural and legal in nature.

It also made me speculate what counts as “sentient.” As we have frequently covered in this publication, even smaller fish have cognitive skills once thought way beyond them, and feelings too. Crustaceans are known to feel pain, fear and stress, and are likely to also have cognitive skills that we just have not documented yet.

But what about even smaller critters? What, if anything, do they think and feel? There simply is no agreed to minimum size of brain considered capable of supporting sentience, so we cannot rule it out.

The philosophical, ethical and legal implications are enough to make my brain hurt. That being said, it is quite clear that sentient beings matter, and we must do better by them.

When I dive, I therefore do not take anything for granted but acknowledge that even the smallest and seemingly insignificant creature just might be capable of some degree of sentience.

This realisation has not only left me more careful and respectful around other life forms, but has also added to the sense of wonder, profound as it already is, that has made diving so fulfilling.

Profile picture for user Chief minion
Chief minion
1
min read
A- A+
  • facebook-f
  • twitter
  • envelope
  • print

Trending

Ocean Warming and Fish Grazing Drive Collapse of Japan's Kelp Forests

Ecology & Science

Blue Whale Songs May Reveal When Whales Are Feeding

Ecology & Science

Young Manta Rays Depend on Coastal Refuges, Study Finds

Ecology & Science
Horned Nudibranch

Nudibranchs: Wonders of the Sea

Ecology & Science
A humpback whale and calf

Marine Heatwaves Disrupt Humpback Whale Nutrition and Reproduction

Ecology & Science
The SS United States undergoing preparations in Mobile, Alabama, ahead of its planned sinking off Florida in November 2026.

SS United States to Be Sunk in November

Wrecks & Archaeology
Lionfish

The Trouble with Calling an Animal an Invader

Op'eds and commentaries
IUCN survey of reef at Fernando de Noronha, Brazil

96% of World's Coral Reef Ecosystems Projected to be at Critical Risk of Collapse

Ecology & Science

Latest updates from archives

Shark

Enigmatic World of Shark and Ray Behaviour Unveiled

Ecology & Science
Sawfish

Mysterious Sawfish Strandings Baffle Scientists in the Florida Keys

Ecology & Science

Understanding the Octopus: A Dive Into Its World

Ecology & Science

Into the Abyss: The Mysteries of the Mariana Trench

Ecology & Science

Light in the Darkness: The Mystery of Bioluminescence

Ecology & Science
beached wreck

Ghosts Beneath the Waves: The Mystery of Lost and Wrecked Ships

Wrecks & Archaeology

Giants in the Deep

Ecology & Science

The Sardine Run: Enigma of the Sea

Ecology & Science

Latest updates

Aladin 100 dive computer
SCUBAPRO introduces the Aladin 100 dive computer
7 Nov, 2026 - 19:06
BubbleWatcher
Squall Track develops radio-based diver tracking system for dive boats
7 Nov, 2026 - 16:56
Bigblue Introduces Adjustable Heated Vest System
Bigblue Introduces Adjustable Heated Vest System
5 Nov, 2026 - 14:54
Ocean Warming and Fish Grazing Drive Collapse of Japan's Kelp Forests
2 Nov, 2026 - 19:49
More
Advertisement

Related content

Mexico risks turning precisely the visitors it ought to welcome into disgruntled critics.
Mexican Malady
22 Aug, 2026    
We have agency
We Have Agency
14 May, 2026    
CopOUT30
08 Dec, 2025    
Michael Menduno and Peter Symes
Thank you, Michael
05 Oct, 2025    
Lady Starfish
01 Sep, 2025    

Upcoming Events & Expos

21 Nov, 2026 ➢ 22 Nov, 2026

Baltictech Conference 2026

Gdynia, Poland

5 Dec, 2026 ➢ 6 Dec, 2026

Dive-Expo

Antwerp Expo, Belgium

17 Mar, 2027 ➢ 20 Mar, 2027

Aqaba Blue: Ocean Future in Action

Aqaba, Jordan

Stay Social

Don’t forget that you can connect with us through all major social media, by simply clicking on the corresponding logo below.

Reviews

Books & Media

Secret Seas

Professional underwater photographer, Paul Flandinette and marine scientist and underwater photographer Michel Claereboudt take the reader on a breathtaking journey of discovery into Oman's underwater world.

Book cover
Review
Books
Books & Media

Technically Speaking

Simon Pridmore's aim in writing this book was to examine and record where technical diving came from, how it developed, how it expanded across the world, who the important movers were and how the efforts of a few determined people changed our little field of human endeavour forever.

Technically Speaking
Works by Our Contributors
Review
Books
Simon Pridmore
Books & Media

Scuba Diving Operational Risk Management

An SAS approach to principles, techniques and application in recreational and technical diving.

Book cover
Review
Books
Books & Media

Marine Life of the Caribbean

A richly illustrated field guide to the remarkable diversity of one of the world’s great diving regions

Marine Life of the Caribbean by Lawson Wood
Works by Our Contributors
Review
Books
Lawson Wood
Advertisement
Advertisement

Books & Media by our contributors

The World Beneath cover

The World Beneath

Apr 23, 2021 Richard Smith
Lusitania: The Underwater Collection

Lusitania: The Underwater Collection, by Vic Verlinden

Jan 02, 2023 Vic Verlinden
Scuba Fundamental cover

Scuba Fundamental

Aug 23, 2016 Simon Pridmore
Book cover

Legends Beneath the Waves – Scandinavia

Jan 02, 2023 Rene B. Andersen & Andrew Marriott

Sponsored Content | Paid Posts

How Sustainable Eating Can Improve Your Health and Reduce Your Carbon Footprint

Sponsor : Sarah Daren

Environmentally Friendly Solutions for Business

Sponsor : Jason Morris

The Impact of Storytelling: Sharing Your Expertise on Environmental Health

Sponsor : Sarah Daren

Questions Divers Should Bring to a Small Boat Viewing

Sponsor : Amy Wilson

Budget Diving 101: Exploring the Ocean on Student Funds

Sponsor : Jane Venety

What Should You Focus on While Writing Your Scientific Paper?

Sponsor : Laura Fields

Wellness Retreats: Rejuvenate Your Mind and Body While Traveling

Sponsor : Diane Hutton

A guy’s lost iPhone found after two days by a scuba diver

Home
International Dive Magazine

About X-Ray Mag

AquaScope Media logo

Compiled by an international network of top dive editors and world-class underwater photographers, X-RAY MAG is the planet's only truly global premier dive lifestyle magazine. Subscription and downloads are free. Published since 2003.

Image
DEMA Member

Published by:

AquaScope Media ApS - Copenhagen - © 2026

A closer look below the surface.

Advertising

  • General info / Distribution
  • Rate cards
    • Media kit - $ (USD)
    • Media kit - € (EUR)
    • Media kit - £ (GBP)
  • Ad Sizes and Formats
    • Magazine Ad Copy sizes
    • Banner ad sizes
  • General trading terms

Privacy & GDPR

  • Privacy and Cookie Policy

Subscriptions

  • US Newsletter
  • Canadian Newsletter
  • European Newsletter
  • UK Newsletter
  • Asia-Pacific Newslettre
  • Other / Global
  • 😪 Unsubscribe

Brand Assets / Logos

  • Banner ads
  • Logos
  • SoMe Collaterals

Contact

  • Contact us
  • About us

Brugerkontomenu

  • Log in
Clear keys input element