Peru’s anchovy crisis reveals the fragility of marine ecosystems — and why sometimes the only responsible decision is to stop fishing.
Global capture production of Anchoveta (Engraulis ringens) in million tonnes from 1950 to 2022, as reported by the FAO.
Off the coast of Peru, one of the richest fishing grounds on Earth has fallen dangerously quiet. Boats that would normally bring millions of tonnes of small fish ashore have been forced to remain in port. The cause is not simply a shortage of fish, nor is it just an episode of extreme weather. It is a warning about what happens when an ocean already under pressure is confronted with a changing climate.
In October 2026, The Guardian reported on Peru’s decision to suspend, and subsequently cancel, its 2026 north-central anchovy fishing season. The immediate threat is an exceptionally powerful El Niño, which is warming the waters of the eastern Pacific and disrupting the conditions on which the fish depend. But the crisis has deeper roots, reaching back through decades of intensive fishing and into the wider transformation of the marine environment by human activity.
Peru’s response offers an important lesson for fisheries around the world: when the conditions needed for a population to survive and reproduce deteriorate, continuing to take it simply because a quota has been established can turn a difficult year into a much more serious ecological disaster.
A tiny fish with an enormous ecological role
The Peruvian anchoveta (Engraulis ringens) may be small, but its importance is extraordinary. Since 1970, it has accounted for approximately one-tenth of the entire global commercial fish catch by weight. It is the foundation of one of the world’s largest fisheries, and its abundance has helped sustain a vast international trade. More than 90% of the anchoveta caught in Peru is processed into fishmeal and fish oil — not food for people. These products are shipped around the world for use in aquaculture, livestock feed, and nutritional supplements.
Yet the fish’s importance extends far beyond its commercial value.
Anchoveta feed on plankton and, in turn, are eaten by larger fish, seabirds and marine mammals. They form an essential link between the microscopic organisms that thrive in productive ocean waters and the animals higher up the food web. Their abundance helps sustain the extraordinary concentrations of life associated with the Peruvian coast, including seabirds and marine predators that depend on small schooling fish.
The anchoveta fishery therefore cannot be understood simply as a supply of raw material for industry. It is the removal of a vast number of animals from an intricate and interconnected ecosystem of living creatures.
When anchoveta numbers decline, the consequences extend well beyond the fishing fleet. Predators lose an important food source, competition between species shifts, and the balance of the food web is altered. The precise effects depend on local conditions and the responses of other species, but the ecological significance of this fish is profound.
When the ocean’s natural engine falters
The extraordinary productivity of Peru’s marine ecosystem is closely linked to the Humboldt Current and the process known as coastal upwelling.
Along this stretch of South America, winds help bring cold, nutrient-rich water from deeper layers of the ocean towards the surface. Those nutrients support the growth of phytoplankton — microscopic photosynthetic organisms that form the foundation of the marine food web. Zooplankton feed on phytoplankton, anchoveta feed on plankton, and a multitude of larger animals depend on the resulting abundance.
This system can produce immense quantities of life. But its productivity depends on a delicate relationship between ocean circulation, temperature, nutrients and biological processes.
During El Niño, warmer water spreads across the eastern Pacific and alters the normal pattern of upwelling. The supply of nutrients to surface waters diminishes, plankton production changes, and the distribution of species shifts. Anchoveta may move into deeper or different waters in search of suitable conditions, making them harder to find and catch. Further, their growth, reproductive success and survival is threatened.
The problem in 2026 is that the anchoveta population was already vulnerable. The exceptionally warm conditions are now adding another stress to a fishery that has experienced decades of intensive exploitation.
The result is a collision between natural climate variability and human pressure. El Niño is a natural phenomenon, but the effects of an environmental disturbance are much more dangerous to a fragile population already heavily overfished for decades.
Climate change adds a further complication. The oceans are warming over the long term, and the effects of rising temperatures on currents, oxygen levels, salinity and marine food webs are making the future less predictable. Occurring against this altered background, the El Niño event is a greater threat than during the more stable climatic conditions of the past.
The decision to stop
Peru’s fishing industry is economically important on a global scale. The anchoveta catch supports tens of thousands of jobs directly, and many more in processing, transport and related activities. Fishmeal and fish oil are traded internationally, so a disruption in Peru can affect producers and consumers far beyond South America.
So stopping the fishery comes at a considerable cost.
Nevertheless, Peru’s authorities chose precaution over the immediate pursuit of the catch. Fishing was suspended in June 2026, and the north-central season was later cancelled after scientific assessments found that conditions were too dire. The proportion of juvenile fish in the population was a particular concern: catching too many fish before they have reproduced undermines the ability of the population to recover.
So, more than a million tonnes of the season’s permitted catch are able to pursue their lives as a result of this decision.
A fishing quota represents an estimate of what may be removed under specified conditions; it is not a guarantee that the entire quantity can safely be caught regardless of what happens to the ecosystem. When environmental conditions change, the assumptions behind a quota are no longer valid.
Peru has developed extensive monitoring and scientific assessment of its anchoveta fishery, and its willingness to close the season demonstrates the value of being able to respond to new evidence. The decision recognises a fundamental ecological reality: fish must survive in sufficient numbers to reproduce, and the ecosystem must continue to support them. The lesson is that fisheries management should be capable of stopping when the evidence indicates that continued overfishing threatens the health of the ecosystem.
In a changing ocean, a rigid commitment to catching a predetermined quantity is no substitute for an understanding of what the living population can actually sustain.
A perfect storm of human pressures
El Niño has triggered the current crisis, but there are many more pressures on the world's marine ecosystems. Overfishing removes animals faster than the remaining population can replace them, through reproduction in increasingly altered ecosystems. Overfishing alters food webs, reduces the abundance of large individuals, and leaves populations less resilient to environmental change. Intense fishing pressure has especially serious consequences when a population is already vulnerable.
Climate change compounds these effects through warming waters, shifting currents, marine heatwaves, changing seasonal patterns, and the expansion of low-oxygen conditions in some regions. Many marine species are moving towards cooler waters or changing their depth and timing of migration. These changes affect not only individual species but also the relationships between predators and prey, and the ability of fisheries managers to assess stocks accurately.
Ocean acidification is another consequence of human activity. As seawater absorbs carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, its chemistry changes and it becomes more acidic. This makes it more difficult for many organisms—for example corals and shell-fish—to build and maintain their calcium carbonate structures. The effects vary between species and ecosystems, but acidification can interact with warming and other stresses to place additional pressure on marine communities.
Coastal destruction creates yet another set of problems. Mangrove forests, seagrass meadows, salt marshes and coral reefs provide feeding grounds, shelter and nursery habitats for many marine species. Coastal development, dredging, destructive fishing practices and the conversion of natural shorelines can destroy or fragment these habitats. Pollution from sewage, agricultural run-off, industrial discharges, plastics, and other waste adds further stress. Excess nutrients can cause harmful algal blooms and oxygen depletion, while contaminants can damage organisms and accumulate through food webs.
These pressures do not operate independently. A fish population may be affected simultaneously by fishing, warming, altered food availability, pollution and habitat loss. The combined result is far more serious than an analysis of any single pressure would suggest.
The United Nations’ 2026 World Ocean Assessment describes an intensifying combination of climate change, biodiversity loss, pollution and other human pressures on marine ecosystems. It is a global problem, not one confined to Peru.
The ocean is not an unlimited resource that can absorb every new demand placed upon it. Its capacity to support life depends on ecological relationships that humans are only beginning to understand in their full complexity.
Peru is not the only warning
Many other fisheries are fragile, even when their problems do not make international headlines.
Most traditional fisheries have been seriously depleted by seven decades of factory fishing, as well as intensive mid- and small-scale fishing. Many are changing in abundance or distribution as the sea warms. The loss of spawning grounds, mangroves, seagrass beds or coral reefs threatens the habitats needed for young fish to survive, while pollution and low oxygen levels compound existing pressures.
Some populations of fish have recovered under effective management, and some ecosystems retain considerable resilience. But the broader warning is clear: fishing industries depend on biological systems that cannot provide the same maximum yields year after year.
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development has reported that a third of assessed fish stocks are overfished, while climate change and ocean pollution are making management more complicated. Temperature changes, shifting currents and acidification can alter the abundance and distribution of commercially important species, making historical catch figures an increasingly unreliable guide to future productivity.
This means that a fishery may appear successful by conventional economic measures — large landings, busy ports and a profitable export industry — while its ecological foundations are unravelling.
Peru’s anchoveta crisis asks us to reconsider what we mean by success. Is a fishery successful because it catches all the fish it has been authorised to catch? Or is it successful because it maintains a healthy population, supports the food web and remains capable of sustaining fishing communities into the future?
The two goals can coincide. But when they conflict, the long-term health of the ecosystem must matter more than a short-term production target.
Protecting the fish means protecting the system
A temporary closure can give a population breathing space, but it is not a solution to the pressures facing the ocean.
Effective fisheries management requires reliable scientific surveys, continuous monitoring, enforcement against illegal fishing, and the flexibility to reduce catches or close fishing grounds when conditions deteriorate. It also requires attention to the wider ecosystem: the availability of prey, the survival of juveniles, reproductive success, the condition of habitats and the effects of environmental change, which have not traditionally been taken into account by regional fisheries management organisations.
Closures must be accompanied by measures to support fishing communities. The people whose livelihoods depend on the sea should not be expected to bear the entire cost of ecological damage they may have had little power to prevent. Emergency assistance, fairer management, alternative livelihoods where appropriate, and a greater share of the benefits of fisheries can help make conservation decisions socially sustainable as well as biologically necessary.
At the same time, governments must address the causes of environmental deterioration that lie beyond fisheries management. Reducing greenhouse gas emissions, protecting coastal habitats, controlling pollution and safeguarding marine biodiversity are all part of protecting fish populations. No quota system, however sophisticated, can compensate indefinitely for a deteriorating marine environment.
We must also examine what we are asking fisheries to supply. The fact that most Peruvian anchoveta becomes fishmeal and fish oil raises important questions about the global demand for wild fish and the efficiency of the food systems that depend on them. Aquaculture, for example, is not a single ecological category: different farming systems and species have very different environmental impacts. But using wild fish to feed farmed animals is questionable given the ecological costs of taking those fish.
A genuinely sustainable approach must consider the whole chain, from the plankton that supports the anchoveta to the final products made.
A lesson in knowing when to stop
The sea has endured extraordinary natural changes throughout its history. Fish populations have evolved to cope with fluctuations in temperature, food availability, and ocean circulation. But their resilience is not limitless, particularly when human activities remove animals, alter habitats, and change the chemistry and temperature of the water, all at the same time.
Peru’s decision to stop its anchoveta fishery is a reminder that scientific knowledge is most useful when it informs action. Monitoring a decline is not enough. Recognising a risk is not enough. At some point, protecting the living system requires a decision that may be economically painful in the short term.
The closure demonstrates something essential: a government can choose not to take a resource simply because it is available, or because industry has come to depend on it.
That choice may help preserve the possibility of fishing in the future. For the ocean’s productivity is not a permanent gift that can be converted into an ever-growing supply of commodities for the growing human population. The oceanic bounty is the outcome of complex relationships among currents, nutrients, plankton, fish, predators and habitats — relationships that can be disrupted when too many pressures accumulate.
If we want healthy fisheries, we must protect more than the fish we intend to catch. We must protect the ecological systems that make their existence possible.
Sometimes the most important catch is the one we leave in the sea.
Ethologist Ila France Porcher, author of Yes, Fish Feel Pain, The True Nature of Sharks and six other books on wildlife behaviour, spent 15 years closely observing fish and shark behaviour in Tahiti, resulting in several scientific papers. Her writings are based on decades of first-hand observations of wildlife and focus on the individuality and intelligence of individuals, challenging traditional views of animal minds. Her work has been featured on Shark Week, in scientific discussions, conservation debates, and international media for its unique blend of field observation, art and science.
